"Will they be different like you?" she asks.
Yes, his presence is familiar but it is different enough that she would not be as familiar with him. The names would be familiar. And perhaps their personalities would be familiar to her.
Other options:
no subject
"Will they be different like you?" she asks.
Yes, his presence is familiar but it is different enough that she would not be as familiar with him. The names would be familiar. And perhaps their personalities would be familiar to her.